MINUTES
STATE
BANKING BOARD OF ILLINOIS
Meeting
of Tuesday, September 30, 1997
Chicago,
Illinois
The meeting of the State Banking
Board of Illinois was called to order at 10:30 a.m. by Chairman Jack Schaffer.
Roll call was taken.
Members
Present
Jack Schaffer, Chairman
Office of Banks and Real Estate
Class
A Members
R. Cary Capparelli
Donald Gutowski
Sondra A. Healy
Jack Lageschulte
Class
B Members
Joy French Becker, Chairman
The Farmers State Bank and Trust Company, Jacksonville
A. Dean Decker, President
and CEO
Central Trust and Savings Bank, Geneseo
Susan J. Dubs, President
Richmond Bank, Richmond
John G. Eck, Senior Vice
President
ABN AMRO Bank, N.V., Chicago
Gary N. Edwards, President
and CEO
Golden State Bank, Golden
Mark G. Field, President
and Chairman
The Farmers Bank of Liberty, Liberty
Dennis B. Long, Chairman
and CEO
Bank of Rantoul, Rantoul
Paul V. Reagan, Senior Vice
President and U.S. General Counsel
Harris Bank, Chicago
Members
Absent
Judith F. Quesenberry, CEO
and Vice President
The First State Bank, Grand Chain
Chuck E. Waterman, Chairman
and Chief Executive Officer
South Holland Trust & Savings Bank, South Holland
Staff
Present
Patrick F. Andre, Assistant
Director, Fiduciary Activities
Arthur J. Appl, Jr., Director, Division of International Bank Supervision
Wendy Bosak, Administrative Assistant
Patrick Brady, Deputy Commissioner
Robert Burke, Director, Division of Commercial Bank Supervision-Chicago
Jerry D. Cavanaugh, Assistant General Counsel
Scott D. Clarke, Assistant Commissioner
David Conner, Director, Fiscal Division
Russell E. Curry, Director, Division of Commercial Bank Supervision-Springfield
Dina Mansour, Senior Corporate Attorney
Dale Turner, General Counsel
John M. Turner, Assistant Director, Information Systems Section
I. OLD BUSINESS
There was no old business to
discuss.
II. NEW BUSINESS
Chairman Schaffer asked for
reports from the various staff members representing each of our divisions.
Mr. Robert Burke reported that
there are currently 163 banks with assets of approximately 70 billion
dollars located in Cook County and the continuous counties. The overall
rating of the banks is very good with 97% of the banks having a satisfactory
rating of a 1 or 2, only 3 % of the banks are rated 3 which is considered
fair. Currently there are no 4 or 5 rated banks. The Office of Banks and
Real Estate ( "OBRE") has not had a bank rated 4 or 5 since
December 1995.
The Commercial Bank Supervision
Division is in the process of revising examination schedules to implement
statutory changes permitting an 18 month examination cycle. A bank surveillance
program is being developed to monitor the condition of banks between examinations
using federal examination data base, call reports and uniform bank performance
reports to monitor growth and any adverse trends and conditions of banks.
Quarterly reports will be written on all banks and reports will be evaluated
to determine the level of supervision needed for each bank. The reports
will also be used to evaluate banks seeking approval for corporate activities,
which should reduce processing time on application transactions. The division
started extensive off-site work in 1996. Currently approximately 35% of
the examination work is performed off-site. The bureau is using the Bloomberg
system to analyze securities portfolios. Very recently OBRE has requested
securities portfolios from banks on computer disks to the bureau. Developed
a procedure to import data into an Excel spreadsheet and then import into
Bloomberg. We have reviewed the letter requesting examination information
from 8 to 4 pages and numbers of requested information has been reduced
from 65 to 40. Examination reports are being returned within an average
of 27 days and we are continually working to reduce that number. Examiners
are training in areas of specialization, certification as a chartered
financial analyst, certified fraud examiners and certified bank auditors.
Mr. Russell Curry reported
the division is working with Central Management Services to establish
remote field offices. The division hopes to have field offices established
in the next few months. Reduce examination work by 30-40% to the off-site
field offices. There are 398 banks in the Springfield area. Twenty-five
charters were lost since the beginning of the year (about 6% banks, about
12% assets) because of mergers or conversions. They are in the process
of reducing the number of districts from 6 to 5. Ratings - 98% of banks
are in the 1 and 2 category, there are six 3 rated banks and one 4 rated
bank. We are hopeful that some national banks will convert into the state
banking system. A minimum of 45 days notice is provided to bankers prior
to examination. Examiners are enrolled in the Chartered Financial Analyst
courses, Certified Fraud Examiner courses and Certified Bank Examiner
courses. One bank is operating under a cease and desist order and 12 banks
have adopted the board resolutions at OBRE direction to address minor
problems seen during examination.
Mr. Art Appl provided an overview
of entry for foreign banks wanting to operate in Illinois.
A state chartered bank - The
only way for a foreign bank to do a retail deposit business in the U.S.
Branch (Banking Office) - Direct branches of a bank domiciled outside
the U.S. with full banking powers, although the FDIC will not insure the
deposits and since Illinois' Interstate Law does not allow DeNovo branching
into the state by domestic banks. Reigle Neal eliminates De Novo foreign
branch entry unless their deposit taking ability is limited even further.
The existing branches are grandfathered. The number of branches have decreased
to a current number of 36. Total assets are at there highest levels, $75
billion for the 36 branches. The examination process is coordinated with
other states and the federal regulators. The rating system is termed ROC-A
and is a 1-5 scale, same as the domestic CAMELS rating. The banks are
in good condition, one-1, thirty-three-2's and two-3's. No problem institutions.
Representative Office - Offices
allowed to conduct loan production and other representational functions.
There are 44 representative offices, 16 of which are banks headquartered
outside the U.S. The Office of Banks and Real Estate has new examination
powers and will start examinations for these offices in 1998. An interesting
transaction arising out of the Reigle Neal and Interstate Banking will
result in the Chicago banking office of Bank Leumi being acquired and
operated in Chicago by its New York State Chartered Bank Subsidiary, Bank
Leumi Trust Co., N.Y. Taking out of our responsibilities for supervisory
oversight and into the State Banking Department of New York.
Mr. Patrick Andre reported
in order to exercise fiduciary powers in Illinois it is necessary to obtain
a certificate of authority. The different forms of corporate fiduciaries
are 1) Trust Company, which after the first of January could be formed
as a corporation, a limited liability company, partnership, limited partnership
and/or any entity could be formed as a trust company. We have trust departments
of state chartered banks, trust departments of state chartered savings
banks and savings and loans, and the foreign bank branches are authorized
to conduct fiduciary activities. However, to date, no foreign bank branches
have taken advantage of the opportunity to have trust powers.
OBRE would also regulate any
person that is holding themselves out to the public as a professional
fiduciary. This was added to the law about two years ago to close the
loophole for someone that was freelancing and actually holding themselves
out as a professional fiduciary like a corporate fiduciary would do without
regulation.
OBRE currently examines every
corporate fiduciary in the state on a 12 to 18 month cycle. In 1995 we
had 27 trust companies, 263 departments of banks and $937 billion in assets
under administration. Currently we have 32 trust companies, 225 state
bank departments and assets of
$1.18 trillion (about 20% increase).
OBRE is the primary regulator for the corporate fiduciaries in Illinois,
we share regulation with the Fed and the FDIC.
Currently there are twelve
examiners on staff. Corporate fiduciaries are rated on the Uniform Trust
Rating System, uniform throughout the country and federal regulators.
There are 6 components. Effort to change the rating system the first of
next year, which will be called MOCA - Management Operations Compliance
and Audits. The states have not been involved in this process. Basically
a 3 rated institution is okay. Some of the definitions for ratings will
be changed. Most 3 rated institutions will become 2's. Currently there
are 8-1's, 131-2's, 113-3's, no 4's, no 5's and 9 new institutions which
have not been rated. In an effort to catch up with MOCA, new work programs
have been developed that are now being tested. Results have been shared
with the Federal Reserve.
Mr. John Turner reported the
Information Systems Section has twelve examiners specializing in information
systems examinations, 2 field supervisors (one Chicago, one downstate),
5 field examiners in Chicago, 5 field examiners downstate. Three information
systems examiners took the CISA examination (Certified Information Systems
Auditor) and passed. Currently 450 entities that information systems exam,
which include banks, foreign branches, trust companies and 23 service
providers. Rating is a 1-5 scale following the FFIEC Information Systems
Handbook Guidelines. A 3 rating in information systems is not the same
as a 3 rating in commercial. A 3 means less than satisfactory. Four percent
of entities examined received a 1 rating, 83 % are 2 rated, 12% are rated
3, no 4 or 5 rated entities at this time. A challenge we face is the rapid
deployment of technology. Our goal is to cover all institutions whether
in-house system or serviced. Another undertaking is a review of year 2000,
which is discussed at all examinations. The goal is to have every institution
examined by June of 1998 using the year 2000 examination procedures.
Ms. Dina Mansour - Ms. Mansour
focused on DeNovo banks. Since 1990 to present we have chartered 43 new
DeNovo banks in Illinois. The statute was amended to provide for interim
bank mergers. Instituted statutory language for reverse stock splits to
provide for SubChapter S corporation status. Limited interstate activity.
Ms. Mansour opened for discussion the minimum capital requirement for
DeNovo banks in Illinois, other states and other regulatory agencies.
Mr. Clarke mentioned that there
have been 17 new charters of independent trust companies and several are
pending. The minimum capital for trust company is $2 million.
Mr. Jerry Cavanaugh reported
on 1997 State Legislation. He distributed Public Acts that have been acted
upon. Mr. Cavanaugh highlighted the following public acts:
(House Bill 1707) - Federal
Welfare Reform, Financial Institutions, and Child Support Enforcement
- Database Matches
(House Bill 586) - Financial
Institutions Selling Insurance
(House Bill 1655) - "Safe
Harbor" Reliance on Agency Interpretation
(House Bill 690) - Age of Illinois
Charters in Interstate Mergers; Illinois Deposit Limits in One Banking
Organization
(House Bill 1288) - Agency's
Regulatory Relief and Technical Improvements Bill
(House Bill 2215) - Regulation
of Pawnbrokers by the Office of Banks and Real Estate
Fee Structure
Mr. Clarke provided an overview
of the existing fee structure; asset based fees, examination fees and
application & miscellaneous fees. He alerted the board of the possibility
that at some point there may need to be an adjustment to fee structure
that responds to changing industry.
III. Open Discussion
Mr. Clarke reported that close
to $2.3 million will be rebated to the banks this year.
Chairman Schaffer discussed
the forthcoming regulation of pawnbrokers and non-bank ATM's.
IV. Adjournment
There being no further business
before the board, Mr. Gutowski moved to adjourn the meeting. Mr. Decker
seconded. The motion carried unanimously. The meeting adjourned at 12:30
p.m.
|